I received a question from a customer:

We just got a brand-new Exadata. We will use it for critical databases and stay on Oracle Database 19c for the time being. Which Grid Infrastructure should we install: 19c or 23ai?

I recommend installing Oracle Grid Infrastructure 19c (GI 19c).

The Reason

GI 19c has been out since 2019. It is currently at the 23rd Release Update (19.26), and used on many thousands of systems. Those systems include some of the most critical systems you can find.

GI 19c is a very proven release that has reached a very stable state. Proven and stable – two attributes that are very valuable for a mission-critical system.

Additionally, I would apply the latest Release Update – at the time of writing that’s 19.26. Also, I would include fixes from Oracle Database 19c Important Recommended One-off Patches (Doc ID 555.1).

Further, I would ensure the databases were on the same Release Update, 19.26. If that’s impossible, at least keep the database within two Release Updates of Grid Infrastructure, so, minimum 19.24.

In this case, the customer migrates the databases from a different platform onto the new Exadata system. The source database is already running GI 19c, and keeping the same GI release on the new system means there’s one less change to deal with.

Why Not Oracle Grid Infrastructure 23ai?

First, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with the quality of Oracle Grid Infrastructure 23ai (GI 23ai).

When I recommend GI 19c over GI 23ai, it is a matter of choosing between two good options.

But GI 23ai has been out for Exadata for over half a year. Much less than GI 19c, which is about to reach six years of general availability.

Every piece of software as a few rough edges to grind off and I would expect that for GI 23ai as well.

For a mission-critical system, there’s no need to take any chances, which is why I recommend GI 19c.

When To Use Oracle Grid Infrastructure 23ai

If the customer wants to use Oracle Database 23ai – either now or in the foreseeable future – then they should install GI 23ai. No doubt about that.

Also, for less critical systems, including test and development systems, I would recommend GI 23ai as well.

Why Not Both?

I added this after a report on LinkedIn by my colleague, Alex Blyth.

Alex agrees with my recommendation but adds the following:

What I also would have said is, you can have your cake, and you can eat it too. This means Exadata can do more than one thing at a time. With virtualization, you can have a VM cluster with 19c Database and GI for critical databases, and another VM cluster (up to 50 per DB server with X10M / X11M and the latest Exadata System Software) that is running DB and GI 23ai. What’s more, you could also deploy Exadata Exascale and take advantage of the high-performance shared storage for the VM images, and the awesome instant database snapshot and cloning capabilities for DB 23ai.

He raises a really good point.

Exadata is the world’s best database platform and the flexibility it offers with virtualization would allow this customer the stability they need for their mission-critical database, plus, getting started with the many new features on 23ai.

The best of both worlds!

Final Words

Although I work in the upgrade team and love upgrades, I don’t recommend them at any cost.

For mission-critical systems, stability and maturity are paramount, and that influences my recommendation of GI 19c.

But get started with Oracle Grid Infrastructure and Database 23ai today. Install it in your lab and then on your less important systems. There are many great enhancements to exploring on Oracle Database 23ai.

Prepare yourself for the next release in due time.